Court: Residents’ Associations Cannot Force Homeowners to Join or Pay Back Security Fees

By Chan Wei Chao (REN 39846), Team Leader, Bricksmen Team · IQI Realty Sdn. Bhd. · Updated 21 November 2026

A residents’ association cannot automatically make homeowners members, force them to join, or demand back-dated security fees as a condition of membership, the Shah Alam Sessions Court has ruled. Free Malaysia Today reported the decision on 20 November 2026.

The key facts

ItemDetails
CourtShah Alam Sessions Court, Judge Zuhrina Nor Hakim
CaseHomeowner Abdul Farid Abdul Kadir against Persatuan Penduduk Jalan Hijau Pelangi and its chairman, Cahaya SPK, Shah Alam
MembershipThe association cannot impose membership without an application or compel residents to join
Back-dated feesIt cannot demand retrospective security charges (dating back to 2013) as a condition of membership
Boom gateNon-members cannot be made to operate the boom gate themselves; he must get an access card within 30 days
AwardRM20,000 general damages, RM7,000 costs, and a refund or set-off of RM1,410

The ruling is from a Sessions Court in Selangor. FMT did not report whether an appeal has been filed.

What it means for buyers of guarded landed homes

  1. Know how security is run. In many non-strata guarded neighbourhoods, security is run by a residents’ association, and joining is voluntary.
  2. Strata schemes are different. In gated strata developments, maintenance charges are set under the Strata Management Act. See our report on strata law grey areas.
  3. Ask before you buy. Check the title type, who manages security and what the monthly charges are.

Projects to consider

Gated landed homes, one strata title and one individual title, so you can compare.

ProjectLocationTypePriceCompletion
BegoniaBotanica.CT, Balik PulauGated 2-storey semi-D, 1,929–2,149 sq ft, freehold, strata titleRM962,000–RM1,587,000Completed
Orchard VillaBukit Tambun, Simpang AmpatGated 3-storey bungalow, 6,790–7,540 sq ft, freehold, individual titleRM1,988,000–RM2,573,000On request

Prices are developer selling prices and change with availability. WhatsApp us for the latest price list and units still available.

Frequently asked questions

Can a residents’ association force me to join?

The Shah Alam Sessions Court ruled it cannot impose membership without an application or compel residents to join.

Can it demand back-dated security fees?

The court ruled it cannot demand retrospective fees as a condition of membership.

Does this apply to strata properties?

Strata developments are governed by the Strata Management Act, which is a different framework.

Looking for a landed home in Penang?

WhatsApp or call +60 10-313 9113.

Sources

This article is general information based on published reports as of 21 November 2026. It is not investment advice.

WhatsApp us