By Chan Wei Chao (REN 39846), Team Leader, Bricksmen Team · IQI Realty Sdn. Bhd. · Updated 17 November 2026
A Federal Court decision on unequal maintenance fees has exposed “grey areas” in the Strata Management Act 2013, building managers say. EdgeProp reported their views on 17 November 2026. The case matters to anyone who owns a unit in a mixed development with shops, offices and homes.
The case
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Development | Hatten Square, Melaka |
| Court | Federal Court, three-judge panel, unanimous |
| Decision | Refused the management corporation (MC) leave to appeal, with RM50,000 costs. The Court of Appeal ruling stands |
| Effect | Unequal maintenance fees imposed during the joint management body (JMB) period are void |
What the law says now
- JMBs (before strata titles are issued) must charge in proportion to each parcel’s allocated share units, under section 25(3).
- MCs (after strata titles are issued) may charge different rates for parcels used for very different purposes, under section 60(3)(b).
Building managers say some headlines wrongly described the ruling as a ban on all unequal fees. Lawyer Datin Harwinder Kaur said the case was about charges during the JMB period.
The grey areas
- JMBs have no power to set different rates, unlike MCs.
- The law does not say clearly what fees can cover when some facilities serve only some owners.
- There is no deadline for a JMB to become an MC, so owners can pay equal fees for facilities they do not use for years.
- The 2013 Act was written mainly for homes, leaving gaps for commercial and mixed developments.
The Housing and Local Government Ministry (KPKT) announced a review of the Act in June 2026. How maintenance fees are charged is still under consideration.
What it means for buyers
- Ask how fees are set. In a mixed development, check whether residential and commercial owners pay the same rate per share unit.
- Check the title status. Whether a JMB or an MC manages the building changes what it may charge.
- Read the house rules. Ask for the latest maintenance and sinking fund rates before you book. Browse Penang new projects to compare.
Frequently asked questions
Did the court ban unequal maintenance fees?
Not in all cases. The ruling voided unequal fees imposed during the JMB period. MCs still have power to set different rates under section 60(3)(b).
What is the difference between a JMB and an MC?
A JMB manages the building before strata titles are issued. An MC takes over after the titles are issued.
Is the law changing?
KPKT is reviewing the Strata Management Act, but no amendments have been confirmed.
Have questions before buying a condo in Penang?
WhatsApp or call +60 10-313 9113.
Sources
- EdgeProp: Court ruling exposes ‘grey areas’ in current strata management law, say building managers
- The Star: Landmark ruling bans unequal fees
This article is general information based on published reports as of 17 November 2026. It is not investment advice.
